.png)
Imagine walking into a shop where the assistant knows your name, remembers what you like, and points you straight to what you need. Now imagine walking into one where you’re ignored, handed a generic flyer, and told to figure it out yourself.
That’s the difference personalisation makes. And your website visitors feel it too.
In 2025, personalisation isn’t a nice-to-have. It’s expected. If your site still speaks to everyone the same way, you’re likely:
- Losing conversions you should be winning
- Delivering a clunky or irrelevant experience
- Missing chances to build trust and loyalty
This guide breaks down how personalisation works, what it can do for your business, and how to start making it work for you.
Why It Matters: Sales, Scale, and Smarter CX
This isn’t about creepy tracking or overhyped AI tools. It’s about showing the right content to the right people at the right time. Done well, personalisation:
- Boosts conversions: Tailored experiences help users take action faster
- Builds trust: When your site feels relevant, your brand feels more credible
- Improves efficiency: Users find what they need quicker
- Supports growth: Segmenting your audience helps you scale more strategically
Key Tip: Personalisation isn’t just for eComm giants. Even simple changes, like showing different CTAs to first-time vs returning visitors, can make a serious impact.
5 Common Personalisation Opportunities You’re Probably Missing
1. Treating all visitors the same
A new visitor and a returning customer shouldn’t see the same homepage. But many sites default to a one-size-fits-all approach.
Fix it: Use tools like Shopify’s native customer tagging or Webflow logic (via Memberstack or Make) to segment audiences and adjust content. For example:
- Show different hero sections for logged-in users
- Tailor CTAs based on past purchases
- Greet return visitors by name if signed in
2. Skipping geo-specific content
If you sell in multiple regions or countries, people need to feel like your site speaks their language, literally and culturally.
Fix it:
- Auto-detect location (or let users pick)
- Adjust currency, shipping info, or service area
- Use local case studies or testimonials where possible
Real-world example: A NZ-based skincare brand saw a 23% lift in conversion when they tailored their homepage for Australian visitors with AUD pricing and AU shipping info.
3. Showing irrelevant product or service categories
Not everyone wants to see everything. If your site has multiple audiences or verticals, clarity matters.
Fix it:
- Let users self-select (e.g. “I’m a retailer” vs “I’m a supplier”)
- Save their preference via cookies or login state
- Prioritise relevant categories, not just bestsellers
4. Ignoring behaviour cues
If someone’s spent five minutes reading about a specific service, your site should reflect that.
Fix it:
- Use smart banners or pop-ups based on page history
- Reorder sections dynamically (e.g. show relevant testimonials higher up)
- Offer tailored lead magnets based on interest
Example: If a visitor is reading your “Enterprise” service page, offer a downloadable case study or demo booking option, not a generic newsletter signup.
5. Not tailoring post-purchase or post-lead journeys
The experience shouldn’t end at checkout or form submission.
Fix it:
- Personalise confirmation pages and emails with next-step CTAs
- Recommend complementary products or services
- Adjust future homepage content based on user stage
What Does It Look Like in Practice?
You don’t need a giant tech stack to personalise well. Here’s what we often recommend for businesses using Shopify or Webflow:
In Shopify:
- Use customer tags and Shopify Flow to automate content changes
- Leverage personalised email journeys via Klaviyo
- Display dynamic product recommendations using Shopify’s native tools
In Webflow:
- Use Memberstack or Outseta to gate or tailor content
- Connect to Make or Zapier for logic-based triggers
- Show different components based on user state or behaviour
These setups don’t require enterprise-level budgets. Just a thoughtful structure and clear goals.
"Is This Really Worth the Effort?"
We get it. Personalisation can sound like a heavy lift. But here’s the risk of ignoring it:
- You’re leaving revenue on the table: Generic experiences convert less
- You’re losing repeat business: Customers expect relevance
- You’re adding friction: The wrong info at the wrong time slows people down
Start small. Measure impact. Scale from there.
What to Do Now: A 5-Step Personalisation Starter Plan
- Audit your audience: Who are you speaking to, and what do they need?
- Segment your site goals: What should new vs returning users do?
- Identify your quick wins: Where can personalisation help right now?
- Choose your tools: Work with what your platform offers first
- Track and improve: Watch behaviour and tweak based on real data
Personalisation doesn’t have to be complex. It just has to be considered. If your website is still serving the same message to everyone, it’s time to rethink that.
Want help turning your site into a sharper, more personalised experience? Get in touch.
